Someone Recorded a Fake Deed on My House: The First 72 Hours, Step by Step

Many victims find out by accident. A real estate agent calls about "your listing" on a house you never put up for sale. A letter shows up from a lender you've never heard of. Or a county alert email links to a deed with a signature that looks a little like yours but isn't.
Someone has recorded a fake deed on your home. What you do over the next three days will shape how long, how expensive and how painful the fix turns out to be.
This is our step-by-step playbook for those first 72 hours, built on what county clerks, prosecutors and real estate attorneys tell victims to do.
Why this is landing on more kitchen tables
Philadelphia's Department of Records had received 152 deed fraud reports by mid-October 2026, nearly matching the 159 reported in all of 2025. That puts the city on pace to beat last year by roughly 15%, according to the city's figures. Records Commissioner James Leonard has said part of that jump likely comes from making reports easier to file. District Attorney Larry Krasner thinks the real number is far higher: "I think deed fraud is going on in a really big way, but there is a small number of cases that are being caught."
One Philadelphia family found that a late relative's home on North Randolph Street had been deeded away for $1. A family member who saw a copy said they knew right away that the signature wasn't his.
Across the river, New Jersey's State Commission of Investigation sent a 56-page report to Gov. Mikie Sherrill and the Legislature in September. It cites FBI data showing 135 reported deed fraud incidents in New Jersey between 2020 and March 2026, with Bergen, Sussex, Ocean and Cape May counties singled out. The commission warned that "the failure to act inevitably will lead to more harm for defrauded New Jersey property owners."
Nationally, the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center counted more than $275 million in real estate-related losses from at least 12,360 victims in its 2025 annual report.

Hour 0 to 6: Confirm it and lock down the evidence
Get the document itself. Look up your property on your county recorder's or clerk's online index, or call the office. Write down the instrument or book-and-page number, the recording date, the document type (quitclaim and warranty deeds are common), the new "owner," the notary and any lender named. Order certified copies. Police, your attorney and your title insurer will all ask for them.
Look for anything filed after the deed. A fake deed is often step one. Check whether a mortgage, a new lien or a second transfer has been recorded since. If a loan has already been recorded against the property, the urgency goes up.
Don't contact the person named on the deed. Tipping off a fraudster can speed up a sale or loan. Leave that to law enforcement and your lawyer.
Start a log. Keep track of every call: date, time, name, agency and case number. You will use it for months.
Hours 6 to 24: Report the crime
File a police report where the property sits, not where you live, if those are different. Bring your ID, proof of ownership (your original deed, tax bills, insurance) and the certified copy of the fake deed. Get a report number before you leave. In Florida, the St. Lucie County clerk notes that this report will help when you work to remove the cloud from your title. The same is true almost everywhere.
File with the FBI at ic3.gov. The FBI's Boston office has urged victims to report title fraud. Special Agent in Charge Jodi Cohen said, "Anyone who is a victim of this type of fraud should report it to us." According to coverage of that warning, the bureau's best chance of recovering lost funds comes within about 72 hours, so file fast if money has already moved.
Report identity theft. Your name and signature were used. File at reportfraud.ftc.gov, and think about freezing your credit with the three bureaus so no one can open loans in your name.
Hours 24 to 48: Put the recorder, your title insurer and your lender on notice
Call the recorder's office back and ask what it allows. Some offices accept a fraud affidavit or a notice of dispute. In an Ohio case, an affidavit was filed with the Montgomery County Recorder's Office stating that a quitclaim deed was fraudulent, and the two defendants later pleaded guilty. In most places, the recorder can't delete a recorded document on its own. Removal usually takes a court order. Still, putting your objection in the public record matters.
Notify your owner's title insurer in writing. Find the owner's policy in your closing package. Send written notice with your report numbers and a copy of the fake deed, as California real estate attorneys at Bay Legal advise. Whether a forgery recorded after you bought is covered depends on your policy's wording, so ask the claims department directly and get its answer in writing.
Call your mortgage servicer's fraud department if you still have a loan. Let them know someone may try to refinance, pay off or borrow against the property using a false identity.
Sign up for every free alert your county offers. Philadelphia's Fraud Guard emails owners when a document with their name is recorded. Miami-Dade's Property Fraud Alert sends notice within 24 hours of a filing. If you've been targeted once, assume they may try again.
Hours 48 to 72: Hire an attorney and get the court involved
This is the step that actually fixes your title. Commissioner Leonard tells anyone who suspects deed fraud to contact authorities and get legal help.
Hire a real estate litigation attorney licensed in the property's state. Bring your log, certified copies, report numbers and proof of ownership.
Expect a quiet title action. A quiet title lawsuit asks a court to declare the fake deed void. The Lee County, Florida clerk explains that the final judgment should direct the clerk to remove the fraudulent deed from the official record. Under general property law, a forged deed transfers no title at all, while a deed you signed because you were tricked is voidable and must be set aside by a court, as one law firm's guide explains. Deadlines apply. In North Carolina, for example, fraud claims generally must be filed within three years of discovery.
Record a lis pendens. This is a public notice that a lawsuit involves the property. It warns buyers and lenders that the title is disputed, which helps block more sales or transfers until the court rules. In Florida, the lawsuit has to be filed before the lis pendens can be recorded, which is one more reason not to wait on the attorney.
If a sale or loan is about to close
Sometimes you find out mid-transaction, usually because a neighbor spots a "for sale" sign or an agent calls you. Move in this order:
- Call the listing brokerage shown on the listing and tell its managing broker the seller is impersonating you. Give them your police report number.
- Call the title or escrow company handling the closing. Ask for the escrow officer and the underwriter's fraud contact, and send your proof of ownership in writing. Once a title company has been warned, it has every reason to stop the closing.
- Call the buyer's lender if you know who it is, and give it the same notice.
- Have your attorney record the lis pendens as soon as the quiet title case is filed. That notice is what makes any later buyer or lender take the property subject to your claim.
What to do now if this hasn't happened to you
Thieves look for homes where nobody will notice a change for a while: vacant lots, rentals, inherited houses, and paid-off homes owned by older people. The New Jersey commission found that existing alert systems are uneven and generally only kick in after a document is already recorded. That's why it called for stronger seller ID checks and faster quiet title hearings.
You don't have to wait for lawmakers. Sign up for your county's alert if it has one, and pick an option that watches every filing type, not just deeds in your name. At Gold Patrons, we built DeedLock, the original AI Title Surveillance®, to watch county records around the clock and alert you the moment something is filed against your title. Cancelling it requires identity verification, so a scammer can't quietly turn it off.
The first 72 hours matter most, but only if you know they've started. Protect your home with DeedLock today, and share this checklist with someone whose house is paid off.
- Philadelphia's Deed Fraud Cases Have Surged 15% This Year (Yahoo News)
- Philadelphia has 152 deed fraud reports in 2026, and one family says a home was taken for $1 (Yahoo News)
- Philadelphia deed fraud reports surge as homeowners fight to protect property (NBC10 Philadelphia)
- New Jersey State Commission of Investigation report raises alarm on rising cases of deed fraud (KYW Newsradio)
- Deed fraud is on the rise. Report urges NJ to do something about it (Yahoo News)
- SCI warns deed fraud is growing in New Jersey, urges statewide safeguards (New Jersey Globe)
- Deed Fraud and Related Schemes, September 2026 (NJ State Commission of Investigation)
- Property Fraud (Miami-Dade Clerk of the Court and Comptroller)
- Steps to Take for Victims of Property Fraud (St. Lucie County Clerk)
- Property Fraud (Lee County Clerk)
- What steps do I need to void a fraudulent conveyance of inherited property? (Pierce Law Group)
- Deed Fraud and Title Theft in California: How to Protect Your Home (Bay Legal)
- FBI Boston Warns Of Growing Title Fraud (National Mortgage Professional)
- Pair accused of stealing house with fake deed plead guilty (Journal-News)
- Home Title Theft: How Deed Fraud Works and How to Stop It (Guardio)
DeedLock — the original AI Title Surveillance® — alerts you the moment something is filed against your property.
Protect my home